Rise of obesity and rise of consumer debt – a link?

About

Through my various scattered readings I thought I had found a link between obesity and going into debt due to neuro-chemical changes in the brain. Two new reports prompted me to re-ponder the link at the population level between the rise of obesity and the rise of consumer debt.

CDC (center of disease control and prevention) released the latest obesity numbers (2007) here. One of their own objective as part of “Healthy people 2010” project is to reduce the percentage of obesity to 15%. Well, only one state even fell into  the range of 15-19% obesity, which was Colorado at 18.7%. It looks like there is a lot of work (exercise) ahead if America has any hope of reaching this goal by 2010. I personally do not believe even one state will reach this goal let along all 50. The data supports the opposite, as 45 of the 50 states obesity rate increased. Overall, the obesity rate increased to 25.6%, which is 1.7% higher than 2 years ago. Wrong direction. The other startling fact which I did not know is this set of data is gathered by phone interviews and use ‘self-reported’ weight and height. CDC understands the potential problem with self reported weight and height and therefore estimate the real obesity rate is more likely to be 34% (as reported here). Add the percentage of overweight adults to the 34% obese and you are in the range of greater than 66% (see here). Below is one graph that I found that show the obesity trend over time.

Now let us switch gears and look at consumer debt.

NY times had a piece this weekend on the rise of consumer debt. You can see in this interactive graph on the NY times site the the ratio of savings (beige – top of graph) versus debt (blue variations – bottom of graph) is not going in the right direction (though I am sure some economists could come up with an opposite argument).

What is interesting for this blog piece is what appears to be a nice correlation between the rise of obesity and the rise of consumer debt (and reduced savings).

Does a full stomach, increased fat storage, and all the subsequent (and possibly changes that occur in the brain prior to the increase of fat storage – potential cause) changes that occur in the brain (I will go into the details in another piece) make the body/brain feel ‘full’ and hence no need to ‘save’ for a rainy day because the ‘store’ is full? Can you afford to spend (and borrow) at an almost unlimited rate if your body/mind is telling you that you are ‘rich’, that you are in the time of plentiful?

There does appear to be a strong correlation between the rise of obesity and consumer debt – but that does not mean the link is causal. But I will in the future start outlining the potential biological link between the brain changes that occur to induce obesity and/or the changes in the brain that occur with obesity that could influence economic choices.

Scary potential future ? Yes.

Can you hack your body/mind to make better economic choices?

6 comments for “Rise of obesity and rise of consumer debt – a link?

  1. July 21, 2008 at 8:50 am

    I recently came accross your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I dont know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog.

    Tim Ramsey

  2. JB
    July 21, 2008 at 2:41 pm

    I agree with Tim. Great blog. I look forward to more connections like obesity and debt. its kinda like a whodunnit novel…keep up the great work.

  3. Ward
    August 31, 2008 at 7:05 pm

    Tim,

    thanks, hope you keep enjoying it.

  4. July 16, 2011 at 12:05 pm

    Very interesting topic but I take issue with your idea that being full from too much eating may lead to the sense of not having to save for a rainy day. First off, when people eat too much they are doing damage to the “pleasure circuitry” of their brain. Just like drug addicts they become numb to the excess food pleasure wise so they feel less pleasure but keep eating to get more, which is not forthcoming because their overeating has “dulled their pleasure sense.” (See The Compass of Pleasure by David Linden, a neuroscientist). Rather, overeating usually leads to depression and frustration and even shame. If you begin to feel hopeless about controlling your food intake, then that feeling can spread and you begin to feel hopeless about controlling spending especially if you’ve been laid off and money becomes even more of an issue.
    I’m glad you’ve taken on this critically important subject and I look forward to reading more.